Jeremy Ben-Amis Dec. 18 op-ed, Redefining pro-Israel, urged Israel to proactively take bold, even risky, steps to establish a state of Palestine based on the pre-1967 lines with land swaps.
Where has Mr. Ben-Ami been? In 1993, Israel entered the Oslo process with Yasser Arafat and the Palestine Liberation Organization. The process was intended to lead to final-status talks on the West Bank and Gaza Strip by 1998, but Palestinian terrorism, not mentioned by Mr. Ben-Ami, sabotaged it.
In 2000, Israel and the United States proposed to the PLO a West Bank and Gaza state, with East Jerusalem as its capital, in exchange for peace with the Jewish state. Bold, even risky. But this, too, Arafat rejected and soon after launched the al-Aqsa intifada, in which more than 1,000 Israelis and 4,000 Palestinians died. The offer was repeated and again rebuffed in early 2001. With Mr. Ben-Amis land swaps included, it was made by Israel and rejected by the Palestinian Authority (PA) in 2008.
Mr. Ben-Ami, the president of J Street, which calls itself a pro-Israel and pro-peace organization, did not mention these inconvenient facts. He was silent, too, on the 2006 triumph of the terrorist organization Hamas in Palestinian elections. He also said nothing about Hamass violent takeover of the Gaza Strip the next year. Likewise, he was mute on recurrent rocket and mortar attacks from the Gaza Strip and on incessant anti-Israel incitement by the Fatah-led PA in the West Bank.
Instead, Mr. Ben-Ami tilted at pro-Israel hawks, among whom he included most Republican [presidential] candidates for their allegedly unqualified support for Israeli government policy, and at their echo chamber of pro-Israel activists. These characters would make a scary bedtime story for anyone whos forgotten that the Israeli government continues to invite Palestinian leaders to resume unconditional negotiations. This tale must frighten anyone who doesnt know that the PA seeks a unilateral U.N. statehood declaration precisely to avoid the compromises with Israel implicit in U.N. Security Council Resolutions 242 and 338, the 1995 Israeli-Palestinian interim agreement and the 2003 international road map.
The pro-Israel lobby is hardly part of Mr. Ben-Amis political right bogeyman; prominent Democrats have held leadership roles repeatedly. Yet someone coming from Mr. Ben-Amis position has to attempt to redefine pro-Israel.
Eric Rozenman, Washington
The writer is Washington director of the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America.