Saturday, February 24, 2018
RSS Feed
Media Analyses
Middle East Issues
Christian Issues
Names In The News
CAMERA Authors
Headlines & Photos
Errors & Corrections
Film Reviews
CAMERA Publications
Film Suggestions
Be An Activist
Adopt A Library
History of CAMERA
Contact CAMERA
Contact The Media
Privacy Policy
CAMERA Authors

Hezbollah Revisionism at the AP. Again.

A May 11, 2005 Associated Press dispatch about a Katyusha rocket fired from Lebanon into Israel provided the following "context":

The Lebanese guerrilla group Hezbollah has occasionally shelled Israeli positions, although the border has been relatively quiet since Israel pulled out of southern Lebanon in 2000.

This passage is fine, except for the words "occasionally," "Israeli positions," and "shelled." Hezballah has launched hundreds, probably thousands, of Katyusha rockets into Israel. The AP itself has in the past described the Katyusha threat in a way that contradicts its current reference to "occasional" attacks:

In Kiryat Shemona - so often hit by rocket attacks such as today's that some Israelis call it "Kiryat Katyusha" ... (AP, 12/23/98)

This passage also highlights other problems with the May 11 AP dispatch: Kiryat Shemona is not an "Israeli position." It is a civilian town. Hezbollah frequently attacked towns as well as military positions. And the word "shell" seems to suggest a more primitive mortar, whereas Hezbollah relied heavily on Katyushas, which are better described as rockets.




As far as AP's "relative quiet since ... 2000,"  an Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs summary of attacks on Israel since the country withdrew from southern Lebanon suggests that "quiet" might not be the most appropriate word to use:

In all, 13 Israeli soldiers were killed and 53 wounded; 6 civilians were killed and 14 wounded. Since May 2000 the following attacks against Israeli targets have taken place:

  • 105 anti-aircraft attacks
  • 42 anti-tank missile attacks
  • 5 Katyusha rocket attacks
  • 7 shooting attacks
  • 10 explosive device attacks
  • 14 infiltration attempts.

  • (This is not the first time AP has minimized Hezbollah's violence. Click here.)

    Bookmark and Share