CAMERA Op-Ed: Watchdog or lapdog? Journalism and the United Nations

Journalists often characterize their job as “holding power to account.” The Society of Professional Journalists, for example, professes that journalists have “a special obligation to serve as watchdogs over public affairs and government,” and that they must be “vigilant and courageous about holding those with power accountable.”

One of the media’s clearest examples of failure, in this regard, is its treatment of the United Nations. While the precise extent of its power is subject to much debate, it is undeniable that it has substantial influence. Indeed, at its very core, it is simply a collective body of national governments making decisions that shape the daily lives of their constituents.

Yet were one to read every page of The New York Times—the “paper of record”—one would find little to no scrutiny of the institution.

That’s not to say the United Nations is never mentioned. To the contrary, major media outlets are constantly mentioning it. A LexisNexis search of mentions of the United Nations from Jan. 1 of this year through the morning of Nov. 13 returns 499 New York Times international edition articles, 1,352 CNN International stories, and 3,254 Associated Press reports. By contrast, the European Union returns substantially fewer stories: 381 from New York Times international edition, 624 from CNN International, and 1,509 from the Associated Press.

What is almost entirely absent from these thousands of stories mentioning the United Nations is scrutiny.

[The full version of this article is published here at the Jerusalem News Syndicate (JNS)]

Comments are closed.