A Channel 4 News “Fact Check” investigation published on Nov. 13, “Revealed: secret files on UK arms exports to Israel,” by data scientist Brian O’Flynn, included the patently false claim that the ICJ ruled that there was a “plausible risk of genocide in Gaza.”
Here’s a capture of the frame – two minutes in to the 11 minute programme – that appears on screen as O’Flynn claims that “The International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued a landmark ruling on Israel’s conduct. It said that there was a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza.”

However, the letter with the words “a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza” that editors highlighted in green, falsely characterising the ICJ’s actual ruling – on January 24, 2024 – was the copy of a UK Judges’ and Lawyers’ Open Letter on the issue, and not the text of the ICJ ruling itself, which, as we’ll show, never ruled on the merits of South Africa’s case.
The lie was repeated in Channel 4 News’ online article about the investigation:

Here’s Joan Donoghue, the ICJ president at the time of the ruling, stating definitively – while being interviewed on BBC’s Hardtalk in 2024 – that the court made no such claim.
The claim is so unambiguously false that we were able to prompt corrections at The Guardian to articles which contained the same mischaracterization of the ICJ’s preliminary ruling.
Last week, we complained to Channel 4 News, asking that they correct the error, and we received the following email:
Thank you for contacting Channel 4. Whilst we accept that the ICJ did not use the exact words “a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza”, we consider this a fair summary of the findings of that judgment. This interpretation has been widely adopted and repeated by legal experts, including hundreds of senior UK lawyers and former judges, and was consistent with the analysis provided by our contributor Professor Janina Dill. It has also been reflected in subsequent UN commentary. The report made the source of the quote clear on screen (“UK Judges’ and Lawyers’ Open Letter Concerning Gaza – 3 April 2024”). We do not consider there is any material fact to correct in this instance but nonetheless appreciate your feedback.
Even by the low standards at Channel 4 News we’re used to, this is an astonishing reply from their Viewer Relations Department. Though she admits that the court didn’t rule that “there was a plausible risk of genocide,” she falsely claims that it is, nonetheless, a “fair summary of the findings of that judgement.”
However, as the video above shows, the former ICJ president stated clearly that the court “did NOT rule that the claim of genocide was plausible,” and then chides the media for falsely reporting that their ruling was that there was a “plausible risk of genocide.”
We’ll be appealing Channel 4 News’ refusal to correct the false claim by filing a complaint with Ofcom – the UK’s broadcast regulator.