Transcript:
Have you ever been chatting to someone who just discovered something new… that everyone else has already heard of… but it feels like it would be rude to point out said person’s ignorance?
Sometimes that’s what listening to The Ezra Klein Show feels like.
Klein’s interviews are long. His guests are often academics, activists, and policy experts. And his discussions promise to uncover profound new ways of understanding the world.
But whenever an episode focuses on Israel and the Palestinians, he has a habit of presenting very old ideas as though they have just been discovered.
On July 7, Klein hosted Rula Hardal and May Pundak. Both are involved with A Land for All, an organization proposing an Israeli-Palestinian confederation as an answer to the conflict.
The interview appeared under an attention-grabbing title: “A Radical Vision for Israelis and Palestinians.”
Klein himself described confederation as a “new political vision.”
Klein: But I do think it is worth considering a new political vision.
But such an idea is not remotely new.
Or at least it’s about as “new” as Isaac Asimov, Pope John Paul II, and Ray Bradbury, all of whom were born 106 years ago in 1920.
Federal and confederal schemes involving Jews and Arabs go back at least to the start of that “roaring” decade, when the British High Commissioner of Mandatory Palestine, Herbert Samuel, proposed placing Palestine within a wider regional confederation ruled from Damascus.
During the 1930s, David Ben-Gurion sounded out prominent Palestinian Arab figures, including Musa al-Alami and George Antonius, about related federal or confederal arrangements.
In 1947, a minority of the United Nations Special Committee on Palestine proposed an independent federal state composed of Arab and Jewish constituent units.
One of the most prominent advocates was Judah Magnes, the first chancellor of the Hebrew University.
Magnes chaired an organization called Ihud, meaning “Union,” which advocated Arab-Jewish cooperation. In 1948, he proposed a “United States of Palestine”: a confederation of independent Jewish and Arab states with common institutions.
Such ideas did not vanish after Israel’s official establishment.
In 1985, Yasser Arafat and Jordan’s King Hussein signed an agreement envisioning future confederated Jordanian and Palestinian states, as part of a comprehensive agreement with Israel and pending certain steps they wanted Israel to take – such as an Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 lines.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas also mulled over such ideas, and in 2018, he said he would consider a tripartite confederation involving Jordan, Palestine, and Israel.
Which raises the question: did Ezra Klein sleep through his history classes?
Klein spends considerable time asking why his guests support confederation, how their proposed system would work and how it could function after the October 7 terrorist attacks and the subsequent war between Israel and Hamas.
What he does not do is examine the history of confederation itself.
How does A Land for All differ from earlier confederal schemes?
Why did those proposals fail to materialize?
And what has this movement learned from their failure?
Klein does acknowledge the plan’s lack of current public support, telling his guests, “I can read the polling.” But he gives listeners no figures.
Listeners therefore hear a detailed explanation of how this confederation might function in theory, with almost no indication that related proposals have circulated—and struggled to take hold—for more than a century.
Klein’s marked lack of knowledge here was not an isolated lapse.
On April 14, he released a podcast interview with scholars Shibley Telhami and Marc Lynch. Together with Nathan Brown and Michael Barnett, they previously edited a volume called The One-State Reality.
Klein told listeners that the argument might have been controversial when the scholars advanced it in early 2023, but that following October 7 and the war in Gaza, it had become an “undeniable reality” that American politics had not yet fully grappled with.
Once again, Klein gave the impression of having stumbled across an exciting new idea.
And once again, the reality is that such a concept is decades old.
For 40-plus years, there have been claims that territorial partition was approaching—or had already reached—the point of impossibility.
These warnings had already featured in American foreign-policy debate. While serving as secretary of state, John Kerry warned about a developing “one-state reality” not once, not twice, but three times publicly while in office.
In July 2016, former Representative Robert Wexler told the House Foreign Affairs Committee that the Middle East Quartet had warned that “a one state reality has taken root.”
Numerous negotiators, research institutions, and journalists have also used the term.
If certain “experts” declared more than 40 years ago that partition was becoming impossible, were they wrong? If they were wrong then, why should listeners believe this latest spiel?
What exactly has changed about these arguments?
What are Telhami, Lynch, Brown, and Barnett offering that we haven’t already heard in the past century or so?
Klein is entitled to argue that American politics has failed to respond adequately to the prospect of a one-state reality. But he gives listeners little indication that top brass in Washington have already been debating precisely this issue for years.
Obviously, an interview does not have the same purpose or scope as, say, a college history course.
But Klein is not producing five-minute television soundbites. The New York Times offers him ample space, in both podcasts and articles.
Whether through editorial choice or simple oversight, Klein repeatedly leaves out history that would properly inform his listeners.
Either way, the result is the same.
Readers and listeners are offered a false assertion of novelty rather than the actual facts.